While many bemoan the changes that are occurring as our culture moves from print to digital media creation and consumption, I wanted to consider the value of digital media if we were experiencing the opposite transition:
What if we were moving from a digital media world to a print media world?
What if digital media was invented first, back in the 1400′s , and then in the 1990′s, print burst onto the scene? What if thousands of startups began developing print-centric business models, and businesses started converting their processes from digital to print? What if teenagers stopped texting, and started passing notes in class? What if letter writing took hold, replacing email? What if blogs found their business models in shreds as print advertising grabbed all the dollars?
In our bizarro scenario, perhaps these are the reasons that people rejected the web, finding more value in print:
- An Appreciation for Slowness
Fewer information channels – less overwhelming
- A Personal Connection With Media
New rituals being created – picking up a newspaper with your coffee in the morning, holding a book as you cozy up in bed at night, appreciating the hand written notes from an old friend.
- Well Filtered
Appreciating media that makes choices as to what is worth reading. Instead of a nation of freelancers all vying for attention to their websites and blogs, professionals band together to create magazines and newspapers – groups of the most talented people, coordinating to produce only the very best content.
- Beautiful Packages
Designers rejoice at the beauty of print media and the ability to create beautiful products that will sit in the center of people’s homes and desks. And of course, people quickly understand that a well designed and edited magazine is a joy to read – something to look forward to in the mailbox each week.
- Businesses Find Value in Paper Records
Tired of the data farms of information that are expensive to maintain in massive computer systems, businesses begin transitional digital files to paper – storing them in cabinets that are within an arms reach of employees. They feel more secure that proprietary data cannot be stolen by hackers or exposed by a mistake from an employee. The need to memorize dozens of passwords is now a thing of the past – you either have the key to the file cabinet or you don’t.
- Privacy Advocates Rejoice
Tired of story after story of confidential information leaking to the web, privacy advocates embrace print as a means to better protect and control information. The benefits to businesses, government and individuals means less scandal, and less fear of hitting the wrong keystroke on the computer.
- Communities Become More Local
Quickly, each town sets up their very own newspaper – reporting only on news relevant to their region, and serving business needs of local owners. A sense of identity and shared purpose abounds, at mere pennies a day. The local classifieds become the source for anything you need in town, connecting you directly with neighbors. Local communities no longer need to compete on a global stage with larger brand that are managed by those who don’t understand the values, needs and customs of their specific town. The world is no longer flat.
- Environmentalists Cheer the Move from Silcon Chips to Recyclable Paper
Tired of gadgets and technology that are obsolete every few years, environmentalists cheer the use of paper as a renewable resource that can also be recycled.
- The Rise of Print Gurus
Like any big transition, executives and print media gurus are created nearly by the minute. New theories and books are published that explore the changes and how they will shape our culture. It becomes an industry in and of itself, creating thousands of new jobs.
- More Meaningful Targeting
Google is too big of a pool to swim in for niche markets who want to be close and feel the personal connections that can’t be intruded upon by other industries. Finally, the local shoe store can afford to advertise to their target audience without being edged out by Zappos in Google adwords.
- Tighter Circles of Friends
Instead of huge online social networks with hundreds or thousands of connections, people choose to have fewer "friends," focusing only on in-person connections. They are tired of the obtrusiveness of the web and the voyeurism it encourages. Weak ties are shunned for deep connections.
- Communities Create Libraries.
Tired of being left to their own devices to find and understand information, students flee from Google, and instead flock to new institutions called libraries. Here, they are given one-on-one help by an information expert, and are less overwhelmed by a tidal wave of information, instead given topic specific books.
But let’s consider what our society would lose in such a transition from digital to print:
Without widespread use of the internet, there would be fewer ways to produce and distribute news and information, and a sum loss in the amount of news and analysis available to the average citizen. Likewise, fewer people could become news sources, giving a few large wealthy players to control and distribute news.
With distribution channels being reduced down to one (the printing press), we would go from many voices, to few. The news and communication cycle would slow down to match the capabilities of this medium, having a profound affect on business, government, and our personal lives.
There would fewer ways for people to express themselves, due to the cost of creation and distribution. Fewer people would be able to create content and share their efforts. While society would have access to high quality print information, many voices would be silenced from the world stage.
Print focuses exclusively on words and images, meaning that that video, audio, interaction and mashups would become endangered.
- Information and Data
Data and information would be less useful, as it could no longer be easily integrated into other systems, and easily found.
But a burgeoning technology – microfiche – could alleviate these issues.
- Education & Knowledge
The world’s knowledge will be available to fewer people. We would become more myopic in the information we receive, and education courses would be available to far fewer people, and at far greater expense.
We would lose a primary way to meet new people, stay in touch with those we do know, and will have fewer ways to find value in those relationships.
- The End of a Business Model
Businesses that make money from digital means would be lining up in Washington, asking for government subsidies for things like search engine marketing – a now failing business model; Google would be left to sue a handful of publishers who are now hoarding the connections, content and profits.
In considering this bizarre scenario, I found myself enthused about the incredible value that print brings. However, I can’t help but feel that a reverse transition from web to print would seem a bit like Big Brother was taking over; that citizens are given beautiful print packages at the expense of freedom of information, connection and creativity. It would give more control to fewer people – allowing them to decide what is good enough for the masses.It would not by any means be overt censorship, but rather, the hoarding of power to the limited space available in an expensive world of print products and distribution channels.